漫漫长夜: 自由党/NDP议席 43/42交叉领先!说句实话,NDP如果真的上台,这是反民主的。 加拿大可能都没有见过这种情况。

最大赞力
0.00
当前赞力
100.00%
自由党要哭死了, 领先NDP 2个点,少数党政府还不见到能保住。 最可怕的是,NDP还有多数党政府的可能性。

说句实话,这是反民主的。 加拿大可能都没有见过这种情况:赢得多数人支持,反而输了选举。

原以为绿党会分NDP的票,谁知道一点作用都没起。
 
最大赞力
0.00
当前赞力
100.00%
自由党要哭死了, 领先NDP3个点,少数党政府还不见到能保住。 最可怕的是,NDP还有多数党政府的可能性。

说句实话,这是反民主的。 加拿大可能都没有见过这种情况:赢得多数人支持,反而输了选举。

原以为绿党会分NDP的票,谁知道一点作用都没起。
不赞同。这恰好是竞选对选举制度的适应。川普,共和党都是在普选票输,选举人票赢。
如果永远是多数人赢(比如城市区),反而是对少数人(比如乡村)不公平。
 
最大赞力
0.00
当前赞力
100.00%
自由党要哭死了, 领先NDP3个点,少数党政府还不见到能保住。 最可怕的是,NDP还有多数党政府的可能性。

说句实话,这是反民主的。 加拿大可能都没有见过这种情况:赢得多数人支持,反而输了选举。

原以为绿党会分NDP的票,谁知道一点作用都没起。

有点儿没看懂,为什么说是反民主的?多数党政府/少数党政府 什么意思?
能给科普下不?
 
最大赞力
0.54
当前赞力
100.00%
有点儿没看懂,为什么说是反民主的?多数党政府/少数党政府 什么意思?
能给科普下不?
他认为票多的反而席位少, 是反民主,
当一个党的席位超过50%的时候, 是多数当执政,
当得胜党(席位最多的党)的席位不过半数的时候, 是少数党,
 
最大赞力
0.00
当前赞力
100.00%
这次省选我是支持NDP(尽管和我没关系)。看我以前的帖子。

这如Sabre所说,票多的反而席位少, 某种程度上是反民主。不管你支持谁,这个得承认。

关键问题是,加拿大目前好像还没有出现过普选得票率最高,反而败选的。 不如NDP和绿党联合执政,就合情合理了。

大神能给解释一下NDP 当选怎么反民主了?只有LIB当选才算民主?
 
最大赞力
0.54
当前赞力
100.00%
这次省选我是支持NDP(尽管和我没关系)。看我以前的帖子。

这如Sabre所说,票多的反而席位少, 某种程度上是反民主。不管你支持谁,这个得承认。

关键问题是,加拿大目前好像还没有出现过普选得票率最高,反而败选的。 不如NDP和绿党联合指政,就合情合理了。
我没说反民主, 我说他认为反民主,
不敢说票多的败选出现过没有, 但是席位跟选票不对应是经常的现象,

我不反对按选区选,
我也不反对proportional representation,
 
最大赞力
0.00
当前赞力
100.00%
按照这个说明:1)现任省长简惠芝有优先权,可先试图联合其它党组成政府。也就是她必须获得绿党的支持才能执政。
2)如果绿党拒绝支持自由党,NDP可以联合绿党组成政府

http://www.lop.parl.gc.ca/content/lop/ResearchPublications/prb0812-e.htm#forming4

4. What happens if two parties have an equal number of seats in the Commons?

If two parties were tied after an election, the Prime Minister would have to make a decision. The Prime Minister could try to gain the support of other parties – either formally or informally (a coalition government, or an entente; see the next question). If this proved impossible, the Prime Minister could still try to form a government and seek the support of the House. An incumbent Prime Minister appears to be entitled to try to form a government first. If it were clear that no other parties were willing to support the Prime Minister, a difficult constitutional question could arise for the Governor General, although he or she would probably let the Prime Minister attempt to form a government.

If the Prime Minister did try to form a government, he or she would need to have new Ministers sworn in. The Prime Minister would then advise the Governor General to recall Parliament and would have a Speech from the Throne. Inevitably, a vote of confidence would arise.

If the Prime Minister were defeated in that vote, he or she would have to tender his (her) resignation to the Governor General. The Prime Minister could advise dissolution and a general election, or suggest that the leader of the other party be asked to try to form a government. (The former advice would raise many of the same issues as the King-Byng Affair; see question 9 under “The Governor General.”) Many factors would be relevant to the decision of the Governor General: the numbers of seats of the two parties (and other parties); whether there were formal or informal offers of support to the other party; etc. Likely, if such a situation occurred shortly after an election, and there was a reasonable chance that the other party could form a government and obtain the confidence of the House, the Governor General would invite the leader of that party to form the government.
 

Similar threads

家园推荐黄页

家园币系统数据

家园币池子报价
家园币最新成交价
家园币总发行量
加元现金总量
家园币总成交量
家园币总成交价值

池子家园币总量
池子加元现金总量
池子币总量
1池子币现价
池子家园币总手续费
池子加元总手续费
入池家园币年化收益率
入池加元年化收益率

微比特币最新报价
毫以太币最新报价
微比特币总量
毫以太币总量
家园币储备总净值
家园币比特币储备
家园币以太币储备
比特币的加元报价
以太币的加元报价
USDT的加元报价

交易币种/月度交易量
家园币
加元交易对(比特币等)
USDT交易对(比特币等)
顶部