回复: 我应该移民加拿大还是去新加坡
新加坡的就业环境也不容乐观,工资高的比不过加拿大,低的又比加拿大低,消费和加拿大差不多,但税收较低,就是地方小,发展空间有限,我当时在新加坡呆了一段时间.现在还是感觉加拿大好.个人意见仅供参考
新加坡的就业环境也不容乐观,工资高的比不过加拿大,低的又比加拿大低,消费和加拿大差不多,但税收较低,就是地方小,发展空间有限,我当时在新加坡呆了一段时间.现在还是感觉加拿大好.个人意见仅供参考
我应该移民加拿大还是去新加坡
- 主题发起人 klargenf
- 发布时间 2008-11-06
游
游客
Guest
回复: 我应该移民加拿大还是去新加坡
但我觉得新加坡的日常消费明显比加拿大低很多（当然车除外。住的话，在新家坡一般只能住高层楼了，要很有钱才能住house）。我上海的同事去新加坡觉得一般的消费甚至比上海还低（哪怕绝对数）。加拿大的整体消费比新加坡还是高多了，税也惊人。比如在多伦多，买个汉堡，本来就不便宜，还要交５％GST，还有１３％（？）PST。新加坡那个１３％肯定就没的。不知道你说新加坡消费高，指的是哪方面？
另外，新加坡的收入基本毛工资和净工资都差不了太多（一般工薪族最多１５％），尤其有家有口的人。加拿大工资还没到手，就被砍了１／３。这个税的问题，可不是差一点点。比起税后工资，实在没发现加拿大的工资很高。在国内外企做到中层以上的人，很多还反映在加拿大的工资比在国内拿的工资还不如呢（哪怕同样级别的职位）。
还有，我同意你说的，新加坡地方小，容易受到外界影响。但说到发展机会，我可以很负责任的说，绝对不会比加拿大少。我有很多中国朋友（３０出头年纪）在新加坡工作的都做到了管理层，手下管一帮本地人（有的３０岁不到都当了大公司部门经理了，管３０多个人！，薪水不菲得很），在公司很有地位和发展机会。但在加拿大，有多少中国大陆一代移民（哪怕读了一个本地学位）能做到管理层？听说得还真不多。语言文化因素太重要了！当然在加拿大做一个技术工人，哪怕labor，薪水也不少，因为加拿大工资差距本来就不大，尤其税后。但说到社会地位和职业发展机会，一个技术工人当然没法和管理层相比了。
企业界如此，学术界也一样。新加坡大学的教授，且不说年薪比加拿大一般的大学多多了（税前都多），还有中国人做到Department Head级别的。加拿大的中国教授，大多就只能教教书了，想在管理上发展，机会就很有限了。
现在情况都不算很好了。加拿大当然受到一些影响，新加坡也不太好。前些天跟我在新加坡的朋友聊天，他们现在都不敢跳槽了，老老实实待着。
但我觉得新加坡的日常消费明显比加拿大低很多（当然车除外。住的话，在新家坡一般只能住高层楼了，要很有钱才能住house）。我上海的同事去新加坡觉得一般的消费甚至比上海还低（哪怕绝对数）。加拿大的整体消费比新加坡还是高多了，税也惊人。比如在多伦多，买个汉堡，本来就不便宜，还要交５％GST，还有１３％（？）PST。新加坡那个１３％肯定就没的。不知道你说新加坡消费高，指的是哪方面？
另外，新加坡的收入基本毛工资和净工资都差不了太多（一般工薪族最多１５％），尤其有家有口的人。加拿大工资还没到手，就被砍了１／３。这个税的问题，可不是差一点点。比起税后工资，实在没发现加拿大的工资很高。在国内外企做到中层以上的人，很多还反映在加拿大的工资比在国内拿的工资还不如呢（哪怕同样级别的职位）。
还有，我同意你说的，新加坡地方小，容易受到外界影响。但说到发展机会，我可以很负责任的说，绝对不会比加拿大少。我有很多中国朋友（３０出头年纪）在新加坡工作的都做到了管理层，手下管一帮本地人（有的３０岁不到都当了大公司部门经理了，管３０多个人！，薪水不菲得很），在公司很有地位和发展机会。但在加拿大，有多少中国大陆一代移民（哪怕读了一个本地学位）能做到管理层？听说得还真不多。语言文化因素太重要了！当然在加拿大做一个技术工人，哪怕labor，薪水也不少，因为加拿大工资差距本来就不大，尤其税后。但说到社会地位和职业发展机会，一个技术工人当然没法和管理层相比了。
企业界如此，学术界也一样。新加坡大学的教授，且不说年薪比加拿大一般的大学多多了（税前都多），还有中国人做到Department Head级别的。加拿大的中国教授，大多就只能教教书了，想在管理上发展，机会就很有限了。
回复: 我应该移民加拿大还是去新加坡
继续讨论
继续讨论
回复: 我应该移民加拿大还是去新加坡
记号
记号
布
布什他哥
Guest
回复: 我应该移民加拿大还是去新加坡
你到底是要去哪?
你到底是要去哪?
布
布什他哥
Guest
回复: 我应该移民加拿大还是去新加坡
我在新加坡生活了15年拿了公民权, 还是移民来了加拿大. 很难比较啊, 各有各的好处. 我觉得新加坡的医疗制度好, 且有效率, 这方面加拿大落后些. 新加坡和香港拥有全世界最低的税率, 但房子汽车太贵啊, 抵消了低税率的好处. 总的来讲, Canada是生活的好地方, 生活蛮轻松写意的, 如果你已经在加拿大了, 就好好的享受它的好处, 不要再比来比去了. 人生可短啊!
我在新加坡生活了15年拿了公民权, 还是移民来了加拿大. 很难比较啊, 各有各的好处. 我觉得新加坡的医疗制度好, 且有效率, 这方面加拿大落后些. 新加坡和香港拥有全世界最低的税率, 但房子汽车太贵啊, 抵消了低税率的好处. 总的来讲, Canada是生活的好地方, 生活蛮轻松写意的, 如果你已经在加拿大了, 就好好的享受它的好处, 不要再比来比去了. 人生可短啊!
回复: 我应该移民加拿大还是去新加坡
1. 税的问题：
安省总共是13%，不是5+13，但相对于工资来讲奢侈品也好海鲜也好肉菜也好都很便宜。 比如保时捷卡宴起价才5万3加币，而加拿大中位工资收入就超过5万，专业人士平均8万左右。
2. “新加坡的收入基本毛工资和净工资都差不了太多（一般工薪族最多１５％），尤其有家有口的人。加拿大工资还没到手，就被砍了１／３”
- 如果对比普通工薪的话那税也差不了多少。 加拿大各类工作平均5万多，税后4万多点。 不过到10万的时候税后就只有7万多点了，再往上就非常重了。
3. “比起税后工资，实在没发现加拿大的工资很高。”
- 新加坡护士平均相当于2万多加币，而加拿大护士全国平均7万多（税后5万多点）。 新加坡专科手术师平均10万加币，而加拿大平均40万加币左右（税后23万，但由于医生几乎都是contractor而非雇员所以税务上有很大优惠，税后25万+应该没问题）。 不过其他行业我就不清楚。
4. “在国内外企做到中层以上的人，很多还反映在加拿大的工资比在国内拿的工资还不如呢（哪怕同样级别的职位）。”
- 国内如果是在北京上海的大外企或当中高层的话那的确收入不会少于加拿大同级职位（外加黑灰色收入的话加拿大说不定还要少）。但关键是能拿到这种收入的人也不多啊，如果有这种收入的话还是留在国内好。
4. 我完全同意你的“在新加坡混要比加拿大混的好”的观点。 毕竟新加坡是亚洲“华语”国家，国内学历经验等也都有一定程度的认可。 虽然加拿大第一代移民过的苦，但第二代移民大部分都混在高级中产阶层里。
1. 税的问题：
安省总共是13%，不是5+13，但相对于工资来讲奢侈品也好海鲜也好肉菜也好都很便宜。 比如保时捷卡宴起价才5万3加币，而加拿大中位工资收入就超过5万，专业人士平均8万左右。
2. “新加坡的收入基本毛工资和净工资都差不了太多（一般工薪族最多１５％），尤其有家有口的人。加拿大工资还没到手，就被砍了１／３”
- 如果对比普通工薪的话那税也差不了多少。 加拿大各类工作平均5万多，税后4万多点。 不过到10万的时候税后就只有7万多点了，再往上就非常重了。
3. “比起税后工资，实在没发现加拿大的工资很高。”
- 新加坡护士平均相当于2万多加币，而加拿大护士全国平均7万多（税后5万多点）。 新加坡专科手术师平均10万加币，而加拿大平均40万加币左右（税后23万，但由于医生几乎都是contractor而非雇员所以税务上有很大优惠，税后25万+应该没问题）。 不过其他行业我就不清楚。
4. “在国内外企做到中层以上的人，很多还反映在加拿大的工资比在国内拿的工资还不如呢（哪怕同样级别的职位）。”
- 国内如果是在北京上海的大外企或当中高层的话那的确收入不会少于加拿大同级职位（外加黑灰色收入的话加拿大说不定还要少）。但关键是能拿到这种收入的人也不多啊，如果有这种收入的话还是留在国内好。
4. 我完全同意你的“在新加坡混要比加拿大混的好”的观点。 毕竟新加坡是亚洲“华语”国家，国内学历经验等也都有一定程度的认可。 虽然加拿大第一代移民过的苦，但第二代移民大部分都混在高级中产阶层里。
回复: 我应该移民加拿大还是去新加坡
新加坡没有消费税吗？
新加坡没有消费税吗？
回复: 我应该移民加拿大还是去新加坡
赚钱新加坡，退休加拿大
赚钱新加坡，退休加拿大
布
布什他哥
Guest
回复: 我应该移民加拿大还是去新加坡
我一朋友南理工读的IT 苏州园区新资企业做IT6年 去了新加坡做IT 现在是管理层 收入折人民币10，000多 买了祖屋 就是公寓 说很多国人拿了加拿大国籍去那做IT 毕竟是华语国家
我一朋友南理工读的IT 苏州园区新资企业做IT6年 去了新加坡做IT 现在是管理层 收入折人民币10，000多 买了祖屋 就是公寓 说很多国人拿了加拿大国籍去那做IT 毕竟是华语国家
布
布什他哥
Guest
回复: 我应该移民加拿大还是去新加坡
我们08年春节见面的啊 新元汇率是5 算出来是大概15，000RMB啊 我当时也没觉得多啊 因为他离开园区的新电时拿6000 所以有点满意吧 因该是刚脱离编程的初管吧 我不懂IT 感觉是这样
我们08年春节见面的啊 新元汇率是5 算出来是大概15，000RMB啊 我当时也没觉得多啊 因为他离开园区的新电时拿6000 所以有点满意吧 因该是刚脱离编程的初管吧 我不懂IT 感觉是这样
布
布什他哥
Guest
布
布什他哥
Guest
回复: 我应该移民加拿大还是去新加坡
Salary Scale for 100+ Singapore Jobs! (2009)
What is the latest salary scale for jobs in Singapore? Whether you’re figuring out how much you’re worth to your existing employer in Singapore, or you’re a foreigner/fresh graduate preparing to join the local workforce, this will most likely be one of the main questions on your mind.
The latest Report on Wages in Singapore released by the Ministry of Manpower (MOM) in June 2009, captured the average salary scale in Singapore for 238,550 full-time employees working in 3,099 companies. This maybe one of the best guides around for expected wages of jobs in Singapore for 2009.
Based on data found in the report, we have compiled the salary scale for 100+ common jobs in Singapore for you below:
Occupation Median Monthly Gross Wage (S$)
Specialised Surgeon $24,300
Managing Director $15,000
General Manager $12,500
Personal Banker $11,713
Foreign Exchange Dealer and Broker $11,412
Company Director $10,550
Commodities Futures Broker $10,200
Risk Management Manager $8,900
Fund Manager $8,762
Business Management Consultant $8,583
Treasury Manager $8,500
Legal Service Manager $8,490
Sea Traffic Controller $8,363
Finance Sales Associate Professional $8,333
Financial Futures Dealer and Broker $8,333
Computer Operations and Network Manager $7,798
Legal Officer $7,280
Operations Manager (Finance) $7,163
Computer and Information Systems Manager $7,125
Research and Development Manager $7,000
Engineering Manager $6,700
Budgeting and Financial Accounting Manager $6,566
Corporate Planning Manager $6,565
Business Development Manager $6,500
Advocate and Solicitor $6,400
Training Manager $6,308
University Lecturer $6,288
Technical Manager $6,155
Marketing Manager $6,114
Personnel/Human Resource Manager $6,105
Chemical Engineer (Petroleum) $6,083
Quality Assurance Manager $6,061
Manufacturing Plant and Production Manager $5,924
Procurement Manager $5,800
Naval Architect $5,764
Customer Service Manager $5,714
Instrumentation Engineer $5,704
Logistics Manager $5,623
Creative Director (Advertising) $5,599
Lawyer (Except Advocate and Solicitor) $5,514
Advertising and Public Relations Manager $5,500
Sales Manager $5,450
Hotel Service Manager $3,970
Stationary Plant Supervisor and General Foreman $3,970
Helmsman $3,500
Shop Sales Manager $3,500
Carton and Paper Box Making Machine Operator $3,383
Aircraft Engine Mechanic $3,340
Computer and Related Electronic Equipment Mechanic $3,282
Karaoke Pub Manager (Including Disco & Nightclubs) $3,000
Mechanical Products Quality Checker and Tester $2,978
Lodging Services Manager $2,956
Machine Supervisor and General Foreman $2,940
Supervisor and General Foreman (Precision, Handicraft, Printing and Related Trades) $2,888
Supervisor and General Foreman (Metal, Machinery and Related Trades) $2,830
Legal Clerk $2,814
Restaurant and Other Catering Services Manager $2,750
Secretary $2,706
Clerical Supervisor $2,676
Book Editor $2,661
Advertising Account Executive $2,655
Audit Clerk $2,599
Tool and Die Maker $2,599
Music Instructor $2,548
Social Worker $2,476
Beautician $2,404
Counsellor, Family $2,400
Insurance/Underwriting Clerk $2,301
Sales Supervisor $2,108
Housekeeper (Hotels and Other Establishments) $2,098
House Steward $1,952
Sports Official $1,895
Hair Stylist/Hairdresser $1,853
Aircraft Loader $1,844
Dental Nurses $1,799
Enrolled/Assistant Nurse $1,783
Doorman $1,696
Medical/Dental Receptionist $1,650
Godown Labourer $1,617
Telephone Operators $1,609
Store Hand $1,596
Garbage Collectors $1,593
Hotel Receptionist $1,543
Sales Demonstrator $1,515
Youth Worker $1,515
Bar/Lounge Hostess $1,435
Pre-Primary Education Teachers $1,409
Data Entry Operator $1,400
Private Security Guard $1,379
Garment Pattern Maker $1,361
Building Painter $1,341
Papermaking Machine Operator $1,331
Cleaner Supervisor $1,330
Wood Products Machine Operators $1,329
Rubber Products Machine Operators $1,322
Plastic Product Machine Operator $1,320
Hospital Attendant $1,311
Car Park Attendant $1,300
Electro-plater $1,271
Office Attendant $1,246
Bus Driver $1,230
Garment Cutter $1,230
Floor and Wall Tile Setter $1,225
Laundry and Dry Cleaning Worker $1,219
Cashier $1,217
Waiter $1,200
Kitchen Assistant $1,200
Motor Vehicle Cleaner/Polisher $1,181
Bellboy/Hotel Porter $1,176
Metal Heat Treating Plant Operator $1,168
Food and Drink Stall Assistant $1,135
Electrical Equipment/Component Assembler $1,114
Hand Packer $1,100
Hawker/Stall Holder (Prepared Food or Drinks) $1,090
Porter (Except Hotel) $1,081
Dish Washer $1,074
Scaffolder $1,000
Pipe Fitter $1,000
Mattress Maker $996
Building Caretaker/Watchman $950
Silk Screen, Block and Textile Printer $945
Plasterer $850
Manufacturing Labourer and Related Worker $800
Construction Labourer and Related Worker $800
Sandblaster/Shotblaster (Metal) $800
Structural Steel and Ship Painter $800
Cleaner (Industrial Establishment) $800
Gardener $800
Office Cleaner $790
Ship and Ship Tank Cleaner $730
Aircraft Cleaner $537
Salary Scale for 100+ Singapore Jobs! (2009)
What is the latest salary scale for jobs in Singapore? Whether you’re figuring out how much you’re worth to your existing employer in Singapore, or you’re a foreigner/fresh graduate preparing to join the local workforce, this will most likely be one of the main questions on your mind.
The latest Report on Wages in Singapore released by the Ministry of Manpower (MOM) in June 2009, captured the average salary scale in Singapore for 238,550 full-time employees working in 3,099 companies. This maybe one of the best guides around for expected wages of jobs in Singapore for 2009.
Based on data found in the report, we have compiled the salary scale for 100+ common jobs in Singapore for you below:
Occupation Median Monthly Gross Wage (S$)
Specialised Surgeon $24,300
Managing Director $15,000
General Manager $12,500
Personal Banker $11,713
Foreign Exchange Dealer and Broker $11,412
Company Director $10,550
Commodities Futures Broker $10,200
Risk Management Manager $8,900
Fund Manager $8,762
Business Management Consultant $8,583
Treasury Manager $8,500
Legal Service Manager $8,490
Sea Traffic Controller $8,363
Finance Sales Associate Professional $8,333
Financial Futures Dealer and Broker $8,333
Computer Operations and Network Manager $7,798
Legal Officer $7,280
Operations Manager (Finance) $7,163
Computer and Information Systems Manager $7,125
Research and Development Manager $7,000
Engineering Manager $6,700
Budgeting and Financial Accounting Manager $6,566
Corporate Planning Manager $6,565
Business Development Manager $6,500
Advocate and Solicitor $6,400
Training Manager $6,308
University Lecturer $6,288
Technical Manager $6,155
Marketing Manager $6,114
Personnel/Human Resource Manager $6,105
Chemical Engineer (Petroleum) $6,083
Quality Assurance Manager $6,061
Manufacturing Plant and Production Manager $5,924
Procurement Manager $5,800
Naval Architect $5,764
Customer Service Manager $5,714
Instrumentation Engineer $5,704
Logistics Manager $5,623
Creative Director (Advertising) $5,599
Lawyer (Except Advocate and Solicitor) $5,514
Advertising and Public Relations Manager $5,500
Sales Manager $5,450
Hotel Service Manager $3,970
Stationary Plant Supervisor and General Foreman $3,970
Helmsman $3,500
Shop Sales Manager $3,500
Carton and Paper Box Making Machine Operator $3,383
Aircraft Engine Mechanic $3,340
Computer and Related Electronic Equipment Mechanic $3,282
Karaoke Pub Manager (Including Disco & Nightclubs) $3,000
Mechanical Products Quality Checker and Tester $2,978
Lodging Services Manager $2,956
Machine Supervisor and General Foreman $2,940
Supervisor and General Foreman (Precision, Handicraft, Printing and Related Trades) $2,888
Supervisor and General Foreman (Metal, Machinery and Related Trades) $2,830
Legal Clerk $2,814
Restaurant and Other Catering Services Manager $2,750
Secretary $2,706
Clerical Supervisor $2,676
Book Editor $2,661
Advertising Account Executive $2,655
Audit Clerk $2,599
Tool and Die Maker $2,599
Music Instructor $2,548
Social Worker $2,476
Beautician $2,404
Counsellor, Family $2,400
Insurance/Underwriting Clerk $2,301
Sales Supervisor $2,108
Housekeeper (Hotels and Other Establishments) $2,098
House Steward $1,952
Sports Official $1,895
Hair Stylist/Hairdresser $1,853
Aircraft Loader $1,844
Dental Nurses $1,799
Enrolled/Assistant Nurse $1,783
Doorman $1,696
Medical/Dental Receptionist $1,650
Godown Labourer $1,617
Telephone Operators $1,609
Store Hand $1,596
Garbage Collectors $1,593
Hotel Receptionist $1,543
Sales Demonstrator $1,515
Youth Worker $1,515
Bar/Lounge Hostess $1,435
Pre-Primary Education Teachers $1,409
Data Entry Operator $1,400
Private Security Guard $1,379
Garment Pattern Maker $1,361
Building Painter $1,341
Papermaking Machine Operator $1,331
Cleaner Supervisor $1,330
Wood Products Machine Operators $1,329
Rubber Products Machine Operators $1,322
Plastic Product Machine Operator $1,320
Hospital Attendant $1,311
Car Park Attendant $1,300
Electro-plater $1,271
Office Attendant $1,246
Bus Driver $1,230
Garment Cutter $1,230
Floor and Wall Tile Setter $1,225
Laundry and Dry Cleaning Worker $1,219
Cashier $1,217
Waiter $1,200
Kitchen Assistant $1,200
Motor Vehicle Cleaner/Polisher $1,181
Bellboy/Hotel Porter $1,176
Metal Heat Treating Plant Operator $1,168
Food and Drink Stall Assistant $1,135
Electrical Equipment/Component Assembler $1,114
Hand Packer $1,100
Hawker/Stall Holder (Prepared Food or Drinks) $1,090
Porter (Except Hotel) $1,081
Dish Washer $1,074
Scaffolder $1,000
Pipe Fitter $1,000
Mattress Maker $996
Building Caretaker/Watchman $950
Silk Screen, Block and Textile Printer $945
Plasterer $850
Manufacturing Labourer and Related Worker $800
Construction Labourer and Related Worker $800
Sandblaster/Shotblaster (Metal) $800
Structural Steel and Ship Painter $800
Cleaner (Industrial Establishment) $800
Gardener $800
Office Cleaner $790
Ship and Ship Tank Cleaner $730
Aircraft Cleaner $537
注册或登录来发表评论
您必须是注册会员才可以发表评论
注册帐号
注册帐号. 太容易了!
登录
已有帐号? 在这里登录.
