无意中在网上看到一网友评论BC省的世界级抗新冠疫情:只给有限人群反复检测,家庭医生,网上医生,急诊科医生确定是新冠也不给检测,说试剂盒不够。UBC专家说可以提供2 millions检测剂,Dr. Henry 又说等曲线压平了再给检测。国际康复标准是在一定时间内连续三次检测为阴性才可以确定康复. 这边居然没症状就算康复。看看这些数字,死亡率2%,治愈率31%.看看世界上那个国家有如此高的治愈率?有特效药吗?没有,全靠自免疫力。
上面评论说的信息还不能确定是否都属实(比如说UBC专家说可以提供2 millions检测剂等),但是引起我的兴趣来对比中加(严格来说是BC省)新冠肺炎病人康复标准,哪个更可靠谱?通过网上搜刮来的资料,简单对比如下:
1.中国新冠肺炎病人康复标准:
据国家卫生健康委体改司司长梁万年介绍,中国新冠肺炎病人的标准是新冠肺炎患者在临床症状消失、体征恢复后,间隔24小时进行两次核酸检测,若结果为双阴才可出院。为防止出院后出现复阳,出院病人需接受14天医学观察。在做完进一步测试后(第三次核酸检测),才能说病人是否康复。
2.BC省新冠肺炎病人康复标准:
轻症新冠患者应在自我隔离10-15天后,患者呼吸道症状消失(不计算咳嗽),体温正常就算康复了,可以进行正常日常活动了。简单粗暴吧!附BCCDC原文如下:
With or without a history of travel, if you have respiratory symptoms that can be managed at home, self-isolate at home for at least 10 days after onset of symptoms. After 10 days, if your temperature is normal and you feel better, you can return to your routine activities. Coughing may persist for several weeks, so a cough alone does not mean you need to continue to self-isolate for more than 10 days.
Here are two examples of differing self-isolation periods for returning travellers that develop respiratory symptoms upon their return:
Example 1: Respiratory symptoms appear five days after returning to Canada. Self-isolate for 10 additional days for a total of 15 days.
Example 2: Respiratory symptoms appear two days after returning to Canada. Self-isolate for 10 additional days for a total of 12 days.
最后说一下BC省新冠病毒检测标准,因为这个和新冠肺炎病人康复标准有关联。目前BC的检测标准是优先测重症病人,和出现症状的医护人员,养老院的老人,重慢性病人。其他轻症的基本不测居家自我隔离。BC省卫生官员邦妮·亨利(Bonnie Henry)博士表示,对民众进行广泛测试,只有当疫情曲线出现下降后才会进行(为什么??)
因为居家自我隔离的轻症患者不测,所以14天隔离期过后如果没有变危重自然也是不测的,这一类轻症患者“被康复“后还会不会继续传播新冠病毒应该也是不确定的,到底对社区工作环境造成多大危险也是个未知数,是不是BC的童鞋们只能靠自我保护自求多福了?